圖書標籤: 海外中國研究 海外漢學 唐詩 書籍史 唐詩 唐 艾朗諾 文獻學
发表于2024-10-31
Manifest in Words, Written on Paper pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
This study aims to engage the textual realities of medieval literature by shedding light on the material lives of poems during the Tang, from their initial oral or written instantiation through their often lengthy and twisted paths of circulation. Tang poems exist today in stable written forms assumed to reflect their creators' original intent. Yet Tang poetic culture was based on hand-copied manuscripts and oral performance. We have almost no access to this poetry as it was experienced by contemporaries. This is no trivial matter, the author argues. If we do not understand how Tang people composed, experienced, and transmitted this poetry, we miss something fundamental about the roles of memory and copying in the circulation of poetry as well as readers' dynamic participation in the creation of texts. We learn something different about poems when we examine them, not as literary works transcending any particular physical form, but as objects with distinct physical attributes, visual and sonic. The attitudes of the Tang audience toward the stability of texts matter as well. Understanding Tang poetry requires acknowledging that Tang literary culture accepted the conscious revision of these works by authors, readers, and transmitters.
Textual fluidity,
評分是個很值得做的也很重要的題目,但是可能是材料所限,寫齣來沒那麼“實”,反而是Sarah Allen對於唐小說書麵和口頭流傳的討論來得更踏實些。做瞭很多與歐洲傳統的比較(記憶,口頭傳統,手抄文化,etc),導讀是對近幾十年西方textual criticism很好的綜述。也談瞭不少唐代與後世的差彆,但沒怎麼涉及與前代的不同。中唐還是太奇妙瞭,各種意義上的分水嶺。
評分The first chapter on the text variation in pre-Song poetic manuscripts is most provocative, shaking parts of the foundation of traditional Chinese philology. The question that follows is how we can conduct aesthetic analysis of poetry after we know that no single version is authoritative, or should we continue doing so?
評分是個很值得做的也很重要的題目,但是可能是材料所限,寫齣來沒那麼“實”,反而是Sarah Allen對於唐小說書麵和口頭流傳的討論來得更踏實些。做瞭很多與歐洲傳統的比較(記憶,口頭傳統,手抄文化,etc),導讀是對近幾十年西方textual criticism很好的綜述。也談瞭不少唐代與後世的差彆,但沒怎麼涉及與前代的不同。中唐還是太奇妙瞭,各種意義上的分水嶺。
評分我個人的感覺是這本寫得特彆清楚,幾個點雖然小(比如拿韋莊《秦婦吟》的幾個手稿來比較)但是寫得很透,講記憶方法的有些地方和Susan Cherniack講宋代書籍流通和印刷術對於人學習方式的改變有聯係和推進。方法上和中世紀的codicology比較並沒有生硬,推敲敦煌寫經小僧的過程也很精彩。我喜歡那個門字寫一半放下筆去吃飯的陰奴兒小朋友,太可愛瞭。
原来只给了三星,现在改成四星。 我是在一堂历史课上读到这本书。读完之后,发现这不是一本历史学著作,作为唐诗研究,在史料上也显单薄,虽然作者在运用西方有关记忆、口头文学、文本批评的理论很有分寸感。 不过确实,作者也说了,他不研究唐诗内容本身,他讲的事唐诗的物质...
評分原来只给了三星,现在改成四星。 我是在一堂历史课上读到这本书。读完之后,发现这不是一本历史学著作,作为唐诗研究,在史料上也显单薄,虽然作者在运用西方有关记忆、口头文学、文本批评的理论很有分寸感。 不过确实,作者也说了,他不研究唐诗内容本身,他讲的事唐诗的物质...
評分原来只给了三星,现在改成四星。 我是在一堂历史课上读到这本书。读完之后,发现这不是一本历史学著作,作为唐诗研究,在史料上也显单薄,虽然作者在运用西方有关记忆、口头文学、文本批评的理论很有分寸感。 不过确实,作者也说了,他不研究唐诗内容本身,他讲的事唐诗的物质...
評分一、通過敦煌本《秦婦吟》各個鈔本的檢視對比,開始探討這些文本為什麼以及怎樣被創造出來。 .強調了文本的不穩定性(作者的缺失、鈔本的隨意改動等) .遷移到佛道文本──as Dunhuang texts from Buddhist and Daoist traditions have shown ,religious texts from the med...
評分一、通過敦煌本《秦婦吟》各個鈔本的檢視對比,開始探討這些文本為什麼以及怎樣被創造出來。 .強調了文本的不穩定性(作者的缺失、鈔本的隨意改動等) .遷移到佛道文本──as Dunhuang texts from Buddhist and Daoist traditions have shown ,religious texts from the med...
Manifest in Words, Written on Paper pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024