图书标签: 海外中国研究 历史 文化史 近代史 历史记忆 PaulCohen history 清史
发表于2024-11-21
Speaking to History pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
The ancient story of King Goujian, a psychologically complex fifth-century BCE monarch, spoke powerfully to the Chinese during China's turbulent twentieth century. Yet most Americans—even students and specialists of this era—have never heard of Goujian. In Speaking to History, Paul A. Cohen opens this previously missing (to the West) chapter of China's recent history. He connects the story to each of the major traumas of the last century, tracing its versatility as a source of inspiration and hope and elegantly exploring, on a more general level, why such stories often remain sealed up within a culture, unknown to outsiders. Labeling this phenomenon "insider cultural knowledge," Cohen investigates the relationship between past story and present reality. He inquires why at certain moments in their collective lives peoples are especially drawn to narratives from the distant past that resonate strongly with their current circumstances, and why the Chinese have returned over and over to a story from twenty-five centuries ago. In this imaginative stitching of story to history, Cohen reveals how the shared narratives of a community help to define its culture and illuminate its history.
Paul A. Cohen is Professor of History Emeritus at Wellesley College and Associate of the Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Harvard University. His books include Discovering History in China: American Historical Writing on the Recent Chinese Past and History in Three Keys: The Boxers as event, Experience and Myth.
當年關注Paul Cohen的時候讀的。但沒想到連這種書的書評都會被豆娘審查。
评分有点像《布汶的星期天》,又有点像《百变小红帽》,说记忆研究,大家太陌生,这种经典模式的记忆研究换几个熟悉的称呼,换成“层累”或者“接受史”,不知道大家有没有感觉?最有意思的是建国以后卧薪尝胆故事的接受史,不管是那么不能说的年代,还是改革开放以后,这个故事变得那么有趣,柯文引用了一流教师的课堂实录和高考范式的作文,莫名的熟悉感,这书模式很简单,但是具体内容还是很有趣的。
评分对于文本如何在时代语境下发挥作用很有启发意义。
评分就比如Cohen这本书,越王勾践跟历史记忆都不新鲜,历史记忆的套路人人会用。但是能选择一个这样的体小精神的故事充分的发掘表现,就是历史学的精深高妙之处。我最近一直跟自己碎碎念“历史学的想象力”,“历史学家的技艺”。其实最重要的难道不是怎么讲出“啥是人”“人是咋回事”并有点儿思维的张力嘛。
评分对“鸟尽弓藏/兔死狗烹”的再述,挖掘其阴暗面,反映的是新时期文人对历史(包括古代与近现当代)和现实的反动与不满——范蠡是功成身退的浪漫理想,文种则是杀生难成仁的残酷现实。至于勾践本人如何卧薪尝胆以及吃翔品粪,对不起,关我屌事?
评分
评分
评分
评分
Speaking to History pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024