圖書標籤: 隋唐史 海外中國研究 曆史 中國古代史 中古史 譚凱 五代史 譚凱
发表于2024-11-25
The Destruction of the Medieval Chinese Aristocracy pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
The complete disappearance by the tenth century of the medieval Chinese aristocracy, the "great clans" that had dominated China for centuries, has long perplexed historians. In this book, Nicolas Tackett resolves the enigma of their disappearance by using new, digital methodologies to analyze a dazzling array of sources. He systematically exploits the thousands of funerary biographies excavated in recent decades--most of them never before examined by scholars--while taking full advantage of the explanatory power of Geographic Information System (GIS) and social network analysis. Tackett supplements these analyses with an extensive use of anecdotes culled from epitaphs, prose literature, and poetry, bringing to life the women and men of a millennium ago. The Destruction of the Medieval Chinese Aristocracy demonstrates that the great Tang aristocratic families were far more successful than previously believed in adapting to the social, economic, and institutional transformations of the seventh and eighth centuries. Their political influence collapsed only after a large proportion of them were physically eliminated during the three decades of extreme violence that followed Huang Chao's sack of the capital cities in 880 CE.
Nicolas Tackett is Associate Professor of History at the University of California, Berkeley.
我不知道為什麼老是有人把這書認作作者當年的博士論文,根----本----就----不----是----好嘛。
評分Digital Humanities applied to Tang history
評分博論 http://history.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/slides/Dissertation.pdf
評分我認為作者還是有非常高超的技巧,一個網絡分析可能引發無數的批評,但是作者在嫻熟的學術自澄中限定好瞭研究目的與研究問題,我覺得這就夠瞭。雖然大小結論上稍顯過時,但是通過量化分析與前人研究的對話還是給人很大的啓發。
評分Huang Chao as the decisive turning point; a sequel on cultural transformation will follow. Not critical enough for tomb epitaph rhetoric.
引入大数据分析是本书的吸睛之处,但本书的叙事风格很是无聊,多翻上几页就催人入睡。史景迁说过:“好的历史学家应该先学会讲好故事。”显然,作者并不是一个会讲好故事的历史学家。不过话说回来,其实不唯作者,现在很多学者的文章差不多都是这么一个风格,读起来大多味同嚼...
評分就论述中国史的骨架,即时代划分这一问题,内藤湖南提出过有名的“三分法”:古代(或称上古)=太古至秦汉,中世(或称中古)=后汉至五代,近世=宋代以后。内藤史学关注中国内部的阶层变迁,重点分析在政治、社会上中古贵族势力何以衰落,庶民力量何以上升,以及贵族文化的没落...
評分虽然数据不具有概括性,但是事实确实是唐宋之际中古世族消失,这一视角为以后晚唐及唐末研究开创了契机……比如中央政策鼓励世族聚集政治中心(从隋唐频繁迁都开始)导致黄巢予以的毁灭打击等等,总的来说,外国学者对于中国历史看得潜,还不错吧。随着关于各种资料的发掘,再...
評分这本书的最大特点是作者的研究方法,作者以出土墓碑为载体,整理制作了大量的图表,以大数据、统计学的方式来还原唐代门阀大族。但在翻译、讲述的切入点和对中国传统的认知上面存在诸多问题,使其有相当多的内容丧失了可读性。我在阅读这本《中古中国门阀大族的消亡》期间,恰...
評分《中古中国门阀大族的消亡》 Nicolas Tackett 这应该是一片博士论文。写论文的同学可以看看人家的结构,真的很好。 两个概念:中古,外国汉学界对中国从秦末到宋初的这段时间,即前200年到960年这段时期;门阀,是门第和阀阅的合称,从士族发展起来,到东晋达到顶峰,直至唐末...
The Destruction of the Medieval Chinese Aristocracy pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024