图书标签: 历史 新清史 海外中国研究 满族 中国近代史 路康乐 民族主义 民族-国家
发表于2024-05-12
Manchus and Han pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
China's 1911-12 Revolution, which overthrew a 2000-year succession of dynasties, is thought of primarily as a change in governmental style, from imperial to republican, traditional to modern. But given that the dynasty that was overthrown—the Qing—was that of a minority ethnic group that had ruled China's Han majority for nearly three centuries, and that the revolutionaries were overwhelmingly Han, to what extent was the revolution not only anti-monarchical, but also anti-Manchu?
Edward Rhoads explores this provocative and complicated question in Manchus and Han, analyzing the evolution of the Manchus from a hereditary military caste (the "banner people") to a distinct ethnic group and then detailing the interplay and dialogue between the Manchu court and Han reformers that culminated in the dramatic changes of the early 20th century.
Until now, many scholars have assumed that the Manchus had been assimilated into Han culture long before the 1911 Revolution and were no longer separate and distinguishable. But Rhoads demonstrates that in many ways Manchus remained an alien, privileged, and distinct group. Manchus and Han is a pathbreaking study that will forever change the way historians of China view the events leading to the fall of the Qing dynasty. Likewise, it will clarify for ethnologists the unique origin of the Manchus as an occupational caste and their shifting relationship with the Han, from border people to rulers to ruled.
Edward J. M. Rhoads is professor of history at the University of Texas at Austin. He is the author of China's Republican Revolution: The Case of Kwangtung, 1895-1913.Winner of the Joseph Levenson Book Prize for Modern China, sponsored by The China and Inner Asia Council of the Association for Asian Studies
一周目刷的中文版,二周目刷的英文版,还是英文版好看。当然看得人很生气就是了,时而觉得载沣是不是傻,时而又觉得,经过太平天国那么一折腾,其实君主立宪制无论如何在中国都不太可能了吧。哎……这才是真实版的“上帝死了,我们需要超人临世”。可问题是,Mao's dead, so is his China.
评分细节很多,但没有对满汉关系与清朝灭亡的关联提出什么新解释
评分细节很多,但没有对满汉关系与清朝灭亡的关联提出什么新解释
评分相当棒,特别厉害,真的很喜欢
评分作者中文功底还是很深厚的,史料也很到位,关于此书看过的最好评论是狄宇宙写的。对照汉译本,就某章的个别“foreigners”被翻译成“列强”这一点,我再也不敢相信汉译的海外汉学了……
短评写不下了 以满汉/旗民关系的角度梳理了晚清史,讲得很多很全。就是历史整理和ethnic relations分析有时候有点脱节,时而不知道自己是在看啥。 我看有人说不买账满/八旗文化对汉文化影响,我觉得这个我还是买账的,但我实在是不太买账这个旗人=满人的等号... 话是这么说,但...
评分辛亥革命时鲜为人知的屠杀 10月24日,西安的满城沦陷了。随着革命军从南面和西面潮水般涌入,他们把捕获的所有居民看作潜在的敌人,不由分说地进行了杀戮。……如果八旗驻防城市的人口是两万人,那么一半人都死了。而且,满城被大规模抢劫一空。 这是辛亥革命爆发时...
评分——读(美)路康乐著《满与汉:晚清到民国初期的族群关系与政治权力,1861—1928》 中央民族大学管理学院 吴磊 徐永志 摘要:美国学者路康乐所著《满与汉:晚清到民国初期的族群关系与政治权力,1861—1928》一书,运用“民族—社会”的视角,着重分析了清末民初政治变革背景...
评分短评写不下了 以满汉/旗民关系的角度梳理了晚清史,讲得很多很全。就是历史整理和ethnic relations分析有时候有点脱节,时而不知道自己是在看啥。 我看有人说不买账满/八旗文化对汉文化影响,我觉得这个我还是买账的,但我实在是不太买账这个旗人=满人的等号... 话是这么说,但...
评分摘要:路康乐著《满与汉》面世以来,广受好评。作者以“满”“汉”对立的视角得到了学界的甚高评价,但他忽视对概念的界定,遗漏满汉之外的其他族群和将满汉完全对立致有失真。该书的研究内容与所选研究时段明显分离,透露出模糊性而不便读者理解。自盖博坚并不确定地称该书为...
Manchus and Han pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024