Editorial Reviews from Amazon.com
Review
"The Dialectic of Sex is a must-have for those interested in feminist theory, both past and present. It's reappearance now, during yet another period of 'ridicule' towards women's rights, is perhaps even more pertinent than its first publication."
-Kathleen Hanna, founding member of the Riot Grrrls movement
"The Dialectic of Sex is a truly visionary work. Thirty years later, many of Firestone's ideas remain startlingly relevant, making Dialectic essential reading not only for its value as feminist history but its contribution to feminism's future.
-Lisa Miya-Jervis, editor and publisher Bitch: Feminist Response to Pop Culture
"Although Gen X women like to fancy ourselves the "freshmakers" of feminism, Shulamith Firestone reminds us that sisters have been "keeping it real" long before that expression was even invented. These power-packed chapters are live and direct, with a cultural shelf life that spans well into our times."
-Ophira Edut, editor Body Outlaws: Young Women Write about Body Image and Identity, founder and publisher HUES magazine
Review
"The Dialectic of Sex is a must-have for those interested in feminist theory, both past and present. It's reappearance now, during yet another period of 'ridicule' towards women's rights, is perhaps even more pertinent than its first publication."
-Kathleen Hanna, founding member of the Riot Grrrls movement
"The Dialectic of Sex is a truly visionary work. Thirty years later, many of Firestone's ideas remain startlingly relevant, making Dialectic essential reading not only for its value as feminist history but its contribution to feminism's future.
-Lisa Miya-Jervis, editor and publisher Bitch: Feminist Response to Pop Culture
"Although Gen X women like to fancy ourselves the "freshmakers" of feminism, Shulamith Firestone reminds us that sisters have been "keeping it real" long before that expression was even invented. These power-packed chapters are live and direct, with a cultural shelf life that spans well into our times."
-Ophira Edut, editor Body Outlaws: Young Women Write about Body Image and Identity, founder and publisher HUES magazine
Chapter 1 The Dialectic of Sex Firestone talks about the limitation of Marx and Engel’s theory. The fundamental struggle is not class struggle, but sex struggle, in which case sex class is so deep as to be invisible. Socialism has never come near achieving...
评分Chapter 1 The Dialectic of Sex Firestone talks about the limitation of Marx and Engel’s theory. The fundamental struggle is not class struggle, but sex struggle, in which case sex class is so deep as to be invisible. Socialism has never come near achieving...
评分Chapter 1 The Dialectic of Sex Firestone talks about the limitation of Marx and Engel’s theory. The fundamental struggle is not class struggle, but sex struggle, in which case sex class is so deep as to be invisible. Socialism has never come near achieving...
评分Chapter 1 The Dialectic of Sex Firestone talks about the limitation of Marx and Engel’s theory. The fundamental struggle is not class struggle, but sex struggle, in which case sex class is so deep as to be invisible. Socialism has never come near achieving...
评分Chapter 1 The Dialectic of Sex Firestone talks about the limitation of Marx and Engel’s theory. The fundamental struggle is not class struggle, but sex struggle, in which case sex class is so deep as to be invisible. Socialism has never come near achieving...
对我个人而言,这本书最大的价值在于它提供了一种看待历史进程的独特透镜。它没有沉溺于对过去的简单控诉,而是将性别冲突视为推动历史和文化演变的核心动力之一。我一直在思考作者是如何将看似微小的个体经验,提升到可以解释宏大社会变迁的理论高度的,这种理论建构能力令人叹服。书中对“主体性危机”的探讨尤其抓住了我,它揭示了在现代性的浪潮中,个体如何被卷入一种既无法完全逃离又无法完全认同的身份泥淖。这本书的语言风格是典雅中带着一股锐气,它既有深厚的理论底蕴,又时刻保持着一种对现状的批判性警醒。我必须承认,某些章节的论述太过抽象,需要多次回溯才能确保理解无误,但这恰恰证明了它不是一本用来消遣的作品,它要求读者付出真正的智力劳动。读完后,我感觉自己仿佛参与了一场深刻的哲学辩论,虽然没有明确的结论,但思维的边界已经被大大拓宽了。
评分这本书的阅读体验非常独特,它不是那种线性的、讲故事式的叙述,更像是一系列环环相扣的论证模块,每一个模块都建立在对前一个模块的深刻反思之上。我感觉自己像是在跟随一个顶尖棋手的思路,在复杂的棋局中寻找破局之法。它对“异性恋规范”的解构之彻底,让我对许多社会现象产生了全新的认识。例如,作者是如何将“家庭”这一被神圣化的概念,剥去其温情脉脉的外衣,暴露出其背后的权力运作机制的,那段论述简直是冷酷而精准。我特别注意到了它在讨论“身体政治”时所采用的视角,它不是简单地讨论身体的差异,而是探讨身体如何被社会文化塑造成具有特定意义和功能的载体。这本书的论证结构非常依赖于一系列复杂的哲学概念,初读时,门槛显得有点高,很多地方需要查阅背景知识才能跟上作者的思路。但一旦你适应了这种节奏,你会发现它在思想深度上提供的回报是巨大的,它迫使你放弃所有舒适的假设,直面最尖锐的矛盾。
评分我花了很长时间才消化完这本书的精髓,它给我的感受更像是一次彻底的思维“格式化”过程。它不是那种读完后会让你立刻感到“哦,我明白了”的书,而是一本在你放下书本很久之后,依然会在日常生活中不断跳出来,提醒你重新审视你所处环境的书。它对“本质主义”的批判是如此彻底,以至于你开始怀疑,我们所珍视的那些关于“自然”和“真实”的观念,究竟有多大的水分。我印象非常深刻的是作者处理矛盾的方式——她似乎并不害怕揭示理论自身的内在紧张和悖论,反而将这些矛盾视为推动理论前进的动力。这种坦诚和勇气,在许多试图提供“万能药方”的社会理论中是罕见的。这本书的结构是高度综合性的,它巧妙地将社会学、哲学、人类学甚至心理学的元素编织在一起,形成了一张密不透风的分析网络。它要求读者摒弃简单的二分法思维,转而接受世界的复杂性和多层次性。这是一部需要反复研读的经典,它的价值随着阅读次数的增加而愈发凸显。
评分这本书,坦率地说,我完全被它那种毫不留情的剖析给震住了。它不像那种温文尔雅的学术著作,更像是一柄锋利的解剖刀,直接切开了我们习以为常的社会结构,尤其是关于性别和权力关系的部分。我记得读到其中关于“符号性生产”的章节时,那种豁然开朗的感觉,仿佛一直以来围绕在我周围的那些看似自然而然的社会规范,其实都是被精心编织出来的、具有强大约束力的意识形态陷阱。作者的论证逻辑严密得令人窒息,每一步推导都紧紧咬合,让人无法轻易逃脱。她不是在讨论“女性应该如何”或者“男性应该如何”这种表面的道德说教,而是深入挖掘了“成为”性别本身背后的历史根源和哲学基础。我尤其欣赏它对语言和符号系统的批判性审视,它揭示了我们如何通过日常的语言实践来不断地再生产我们试图反抗的那些结构。这本书读起来并不轻松,需要反复咀嚼那些晦涩的术语和复杂的辩证关系,但一旦领悟,你再看世界的方式就会彻底改变。它迫使你质疑一切你曾深信不疑的“常识”,这种智力上的挑战感,才是它最大的魅力所在。
评分老实讲,这本书给我的感觉是它在用一种近乎“激进”的视角重塑了对“人性”的理解。我最初抱着了解性别理论的初衷翻开它,结果却发现自己被拽进了一个关于“解放”和“革命”的宏大叙事中。它不仅仅停留在批判层面,更重要的是,它提出了一种超越现有二元对立的想象空间。那种对既有社会形态的彻底否定,那种对未来可能性的执着探寻,读起来让人热血沸腾,又带着一丝彻骨的悲凉。作者似乎不满足于修修补补,她想要的是彻底的颠覆。我反复思考了其中关于“消费主义陷阱”如何与性别角色深度耦合的部分,这简直是精准地描绘了我们当代生活中的许多困境——我们以为自己在自由选择,实际上却在按照既定的剧本扮演角色。这本书的行文风格非常具有个人色彩,带着一种不容置疑的先知式的断言,这让它在学术界可能存在争议,但对于像我这样渴望寻找深刻思想支撑的读者来说,这种强烈的个人意志反而提供了一种可靠的锚点。读完后,我感觉自己像完成了一场漫长而艰苦的智力攀登,虽然疲惫,但视野却开阔了许多。
评分在激进女权式微和被污名化的今天,是时候重读这本书了唔。Firestone, a founder of radical feminism, brought together the dialectical materialism of Marx and the psychoanalytic insights of Freud in an effort to develop a materialist analysis of women’s oppression that was inclusive of the dimensions of class and race
评分在激进女权式微和被污名化的今天,是时候重读这本书了唔。Firestone, a founder of radical feminism, brought together the dialectical materialism of Marx and the psychoanalytic insights of Freud in an effort to develop a materialist analysis of women’s oppression that was inclusive of the dimensions of class and race
评分在激进女权式微和被污名化的今天,是时候重读这本书了唔。Firestone, a founder of radical feminism, brought together the dialectical materialism of Marx and the psychoanalytic insights of Freud in an effort to develop a materialist analysis of women’s oppression that was inclusive of the dimensions of class and race
评分Some chapters appear fascinating, e.g. the interpretation of children and women's oppression via Freudianism, while some are less convincing such as the attempt to equate racism with sexism extended.
评分Some chapters appear fascinating, e.g. the interpretation of children and women's oppression via Freudianism, while some are less convincing such as the attempt to equate racism with sexism extended.
本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 qciss.net All Rights Reserved. 小哈图书下载中心 版权所有