图书标签: 伦理学 哲学 西方哲学 道德哲学 哲學 功利主义 Bernard.Williams 近代
发表于2024-11-22
Utilitarianism pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
Two essays on utilitarianism, written from opposite points of view, by J. J. C. Smart and Bernard Williams. In the first part of the book Professor Smart advocates a modern and sophisticated version of classical utilitarianism; he tries to formulate a consistent and persuasive elaboration of the doctrine that the rightness and wrongness of actions is determined solely by their consequences, and in particular their consequences for the sum total of human happiness. This is a revised version of Professor Smart's famous essay 'an outline of a system of utilitarian ethics', first published in 1961 but long unobtainable. In Part II Bernard Williams offers a sustained and vigorous critique of utilitarian assumptions, arguments and ideals. He finds inadequate the theory of action implied by utilitarianism, and he argues that utilitarianism fails to engage at a serious level with the real problems of moral and political philosophy, and fails to make sense of notions such as integrity, or even human happiness itself. Both authors are agreed on utilitarianism's importance: it cuts across a number of different philosophical disputes and combines a systematic account of mata-ethical problems with a distinctive and substantive moral stand. It thus is, or involves, philosophy in both the traditional and the narrower, professional sense of the word, and is a key topic (often the first topic) in introductory philosophy courses. This book should also be of interest to welfare economists, political scientists and decision-theorists.
[澳]J.J.C.斯玛特,当代著名哲学家,学术上深受英国传统功利主义思想影响,其哲学教育完成于牛津大学,此后长年执教于澳大利亚阿德莱德大学和澳大利亚国立大学。
[英]伯纳德·威廉斯,当代道德哲学领域首屈一指的大师,早年在牛津大学研究哲学和古典学,曾先后担任伦敦大学、剑桥大学、牛津大学和加州大学伯克利分校的
两个正方反方的哲学家连terminology都不肯用一样的。是有多么固守自己的体系啊。不过话说回来,Great philosophers are all system builders, 所以也是可以理解了。
评分Williams的批评其实蛮符合我的直觉,可能是因为先读了他的集子。而且我总觉得Smart强调action的姿势简直就是一种“坍塌”,功利主义在公共性上的优势就这么被他消解掉了。
评分Smart文辞简洁,Bernard Williams艰涩却充满insingt.
评分文辞华美,逻辑清楚——只可惜这些都不能保证说理的正确
评分也许是与前研究的对话意识太强,两位dalao的论点都是走一路扔一路……
p39幸福是一种描述性的概念,但同时也是评价性的。在傻子的快乐和苏格拉底的痛苦之间,除了快乐与否的状态之外,还有对其可欲求状态的评判。 p64在大多数实际情形中,应该做什么是一种经验性的分歧。终极价值并不需要完全一致,只需要差不多接近即可。 p93西季威克所说的“赞美...
评分 评分 评分 评分Utilitarianism pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024