Can faith-based counselors be held to the same standard of legal accountability as secular ones? Or does the broad shield of religious freedom protect them absolutely, no matter how incompetent or negligent their actions might be? After Kenneth Nally put a shotgun to his head and pulled the trigger in early 1979, finding the right answers to those questions became both much more urgent and much more difficult. Mark Weitz shows why.Following his suicide, Nally's parents filed a wrongful death suit against their son's fundamentalist church, alleging that its pastoral counselors had failed to steer him toward the professional help they thought he needed and even dissuaded him from seeking secular help. The resulting legal case lasted nearly a decade, alarmed church leaders of every faith, and transformed judicial thought in this highly sensitive area of American life.Nally v. Grace Community Church of the Valley was the nation's first case to allege "clergy malpractice", one that challenged the freedom of religious leaders to counsel their parishioners. Initially dismissed on religious freedom grounds, the parents' suit was twice reinstated by an appeals court, only to be overturned by a unanimous vote by the California State Supreme Court in 1988. But that decision was made on very narrow grounds, leaving open the likelihood of future court challenges.As told by Weitz, the Nally case is as much a story of modern America as it is an account of courtroom proceedings. By examining both the rise of the fundamentalist movement in the Los Angeles area in the 1960s and 1970s and the social pressures with which Kenneth Nally struggled, he reveals how a culture based on personalachievement came into direct conflict with one based on the search for salvation. He also shows the difficulty of deciding a case in which the competing claims -- religious freedom and professional accountability -- both rest on key principles revered in American society.Based on interviews with participants on both sides of this drama, as well as extensive research in public records, Weitz provides a compassionate, fair-minded, and illuminating account of a very difficult case with unpredictable ramifications for the future.
评分
评分
评分
评分
从一个纯粹的阅读爱好者角度来看,这本书的结构组织堪称典范。它成功地将复杂的法律条文、繁琐的教会章程,转化为大众读者可以理解且津津乐道的故事线索。我可以想象,如果这本书被改编成纪录片或者影视剧,绝对会引起巨大的社会轰动。最让我赞叹的是作者在处理受害者叙事时的精准拿捏——既给予了他们充分的尊重和发声的机会,又确保了整体论点的严谨性,避免了陷入纯粹的情感宣泄。书中的图表和时间线梳理得极其清晰,帮助我迅速理清了几个跨越数十年的复杂案件的来龙去脉。总而言之,这本书提供了一个无与伦比的视角,去观察一个看似坚不可摧的社会支柱是如何在内部腐蚀下摇摇欲坠的。它不是一本读来让人心情愉悦的书,但绝对是一本读完后让你感觉“世界观被拓宽了”的必读之作。
评分这本书给我的冲击是,它像一把锋利的手术刀,精准地剖开了现代社会中一个长期被忽视的、近乎神圣化的领域——教会的内部运作及其法律责任的真空地带。我本来以为这会是一本枯燥的法律文集或者仅仅是社会新闻的堆砌,但事实远比想象的要精彩和引人入胜得多。叙事节奏的把控非常到位,高潮迭起,每一个章节都像是新的证据链被呈上法庭,逻辑严密到令人无法辩驳。作者似乎穷尽了所有可以接触到的官方文件和私人证词,将那些原本隐藏在深层结构里的阴影,一一暴露在阳光之下。更让我震撼的是,它不仅仅关注于受害者权益的伸张,更在探讨一个更宏大的哲学问题:当一个组织宣称自己高于世俗法律和道德审判时,我们社会该如何与之周旋?阅读过程中,我好几次不得不停下来,喝口水,平复一下情绪,因为那种智识上的满足感和道德上的愤怒感交织在一起,形成了一种极为复杂的情绪体验。它迫使你重新审视你从小被灌输的关于神职人员的刻板印象。
评分这本书,光是书名《Clergy Malpractice in America》,就足以让人感到脊背发凉,心头一紧。我是在一个偶然的契机下翻到它的,当时我对这个主题几乎一无所知,只觉得这名字带着一种沉重的、近乎禁忌的色彩。然而,一旦深入阅读,那种被揭开的、令人不安的真相便如潮水般涌来,完全超出了我原有的想象。作者的笔触极其犀利,他没有采取那种浮于表面的道德谴责,而是深入剖析了制度性的漏洞、权力的滥用以及信仰体系内部的灰色地带。书中引用的案例,有的令人拍案而起,有的则让人陷入深深的沉默,思考宗教机构在社会结构中到底扮演了何种复杂的角色。我尤其欣赏作者那种近乎人类学家般的冷静观察,他试图理解“为什么”这些事情会发生,而不仅仅是停留在“发生了什么”的层面。这种深挖根源的叙事方式,让整本书的厚重感和思想的穿透力大大增强。读完之后,我对“信任”这个概念有了全新的认识,尤其是当这种信任寄托在一个拥有巨大精神权威的群体身上时,其潜在的风险是何等巨大。
评分坦白说,我抱着一种批判性的、略带怀疑的态度开始阅读此书的,因为涉及宗教和权力的话题,往往很容易走向偏激或片面。然而,这部作品的专业性和平衡性令人印象深刻。作者似乎竭力避免将所有神职人员都描绘成一丘之貉,而是着重分析了那些使得“渎职”行为得以滋生的系统性环境。我发现,很多问题并非出在某几个“坏人”身上,而是根植于教阶制度的僵化、问责机制的缺失,以及民众盲目服从的心理惯性。书中对美国不同教派在处理危机事件时的法律策略进行了细致的对比分析,这种跨领域的比较视角极大地拓宽了我的视野。读到关于“沉默的文化”如何被构建和维持时,我仿佛置身于一个密不透风的围城之中,感受着受害者寻求公正的每一步都充满了荆棘。这本书的价值,不仅在于揭露了丑闻,更在于它提供了一份详尽的、操作层面的“反思蓝图”。
评分这部作品的文风实在是太具感染力了,它不像很多学术著作那样高高在上,反而充满了人情味和紧迫感。作者似乎是一位资深的调查记者,带着对正义近乎偏执的追求,穿梭于法庭、教堂和受害者家庭之间。我能清晰地感受到,每一段文字的背后,都凝结着大量的案头工作和无数次艰难的访谈。尤其是对几桩标志性案件的重述,简直是教科书级别的叙事。他没有使用煽情的语言,而是用无可辩驳的事实和冷峻的逻辑将读者一步步推向结论。我个人的阅读体验是,它更像是一部社会惊悚片,只不过这里的“怪物”不是鬼魂,而是被制度保护起来的权力结构。读完之后,我开始思考,这种“专业失职”的概念,是否可以被推广到其他看似神圣的职业领域,比如医学、教育,以期建立更具弹性和透明度的监管体系。这是一本真正具有社会改革潜力的著作。
评分 评分 评分 评分 评分本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 qciss.net All Rights Reserved. 小哈图书下载中心 版权所有