圖書標籤: 颱灣 海外中國研究 颱灣 人類學 社會學 颱灣研究 中國研究 近現代史
发表于2024-11-23
Is Taiwan Chinese? pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024
boring, boring, boring... keywords: narrative of unfolding, social experience.
評分5月初在係裏聽過澳洲一學者的講座,Taiwan is NOT Part of China,雖然覺得沒有必要喊口號一樣,內容還是很中肯。記得那位教授說:臺灣不需要獨立,因爲它從來就不從屬中國。the historicization of Taiwan reads like the Chapter 2 of this monograph.唯一的遺憾是沒有historicize China. 明朝=中國?大清=中國?中共=中國?說臺灣不屬於中國,也需把中國碎片化historicize, 而不是把中國essentialize爲一個total, holistic, and unchanging entity.如果你認同清朝=中國,那論題就不成立瞭,否則如何解釋1683-1895這兩百年歷史?
評分書應該這麼寫
評分#Melissa J. Brown can to some degree be seen as a companion of Dai Baocun, due to the common claim on the significant role of Taiwanese identity in the Taiwan issue. But even so, the more rigorous research approach and the less incisive political preference in Brown`s this book still prove that her argument is way more sophisticated than Dai`s.
評分標題可以換一換。談的當然是族群身份的建構,颱灣講的是原住民,書另一半討論瞭恩施的土傢族,這麼一比較就有趣多瞭。值得肯定的是作者跑瞭些檔案館,有一些曆史材料。
評分
評分
評分
評分
Is Taiwan Chinese? pdf epub mobi txt 電子書 下載 2024