图书标签: 中东  伊斯蘭  VSI  Oxford  非虚构  傳記  伊斯兰   

喜欢 Muhammad 的读者还喜欢

sunday school material + scholarly analysis

Voltaire wrote about the science of history, 'We can believe people in what they say about themselves if it is to their disadvantage.' This provides a central rule for modern historians: if a report contains something that makes its author or their side in a dispute look bad, it is probably true, why would they made it up?--P80

三个部分：穆斯林经典叙事中的穆罕默德；现代批判历史学对这种叙事的研究和反思；现代语境下对穆罕默德身份的重构。主要的点都讲到了并且讲的很清楚，但是第一部分的比重实在太大，都让我怀疑作者是不是穆斯林了，我还是更期待这书里有更多分析和学术史的内容，像关于圣经的那几本Very Short Introduction那样。

Voltaire wrote about the science of history, 'We can believe people in what they say about themselves if it is to their disadvantage.' This provides a central rule for modern historians: if a report contains something that makes its author or their side in a dispute look bad, it is probably true, why would they made it up?--P80

Voltaire wrote about the science of history, 'We can believe people in what they say about themselves if it is to their disadvantage.' This provides a central rule for modern historians: if a report contains something that makes its author or their side in a dispute look bad, it is probably true, why would they made it up?--P80