图书标签: 慈继伟 历史 中国革命 哲学 海外中国研究 当代中国 英文原版 政治哲学
发表于2024-11-22
Dialectic of the Chinese Revolution pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
In a comparative philosophical perspective, Jiwei Ci provides an thought-provoking philosophical and psychological interpretation of the history of Chinese revolution from Maoist utopianism to reform-era hedonism. Ci argues against the common conception of the Maoist project as ascetic utopianism. Instead, he sees sublimated hedonism as an integral part of utopianism, and through ideological bankruptcy caused by the irreconcilable separation between reality and meaning creates nihilism, in turn leading to full-scale hedonism. Under this universalizing framework, Ci presents the materialist roots of Maoism his detour on the road to capitalism, reframes the Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution as struggles against the routinization or depersonalization of charisma,and even reinterprets the Democracy movement and recent anti-corruption agitation as inherently hedonistic.
#一个想法,不一定对#哲学性的历史叙述有时候会出现的一个问题是,不知道主语是谁。当一段叙述的形式是「China」如何如何,或者「We」如何如何的时候,很难让人分辨是不是带有某种概括性的national character的假设
评分老师的老师 = =
评分作者写于90-91年,在序言中也表达了这是对刚发生的历史事件的个人理解和回应,不是历史论述——的确,很多时候慈的行文更像一场有激情的、无所谓过度泛化和论证牵强的演说,而不是书背后出版社用于宣传的定为词“历史”、“政治科学”研究。书的毛病很多,也有很多聪明的逻辑推理。问题之一:作者虽然反复强调这是“personal response",却时时跳转于“我”、“我们”、“(我作为观察者所旁观的)他们”三个角色间。二,过度的情感注入弱化了逻辑推理,比如他给出Mao's Morality的概念,忽然间又忍不住大谈毛时代以后“道德沦丧”。这本书作为一家之言可以一读,但就像作者反复在序言中强调,这只是“个人理解”。
评分老师的老师 = =
评分神作!思路清晰,行文精炼,论点极有说服力。
评分
评分
评分
评分
Dialectic of the Chinese Revolution pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024