图书标签: 电影 姜文 谢柏柯 评论 论文 艺术评论 艺术史 艺
发表于2024-11-07
Body in Question pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
In the Heat of the Sun and Devils on the Doorstep are two of the finest and most honored Chinese films ever made. Body in Question is the first book to thoroughly examine these groundbreaking works and one of the first books in English to study individual Chinese films in depth.
These two award-winning films by renowned director-actor Jiang Wen and cinematographer Gu Changwei are unsurpassed in China for their exquisite attention to realistic detail, their stylistic range, their emotional breadth, and their razor-like commentary on contemporary China. In scenes that range from hilarious to horrific, China's ruling elite and its complicated relationship with Japan are subjected to the filmmakers' ironic treatment and profound concern with social justice. In the Heat of the Sun has become unavailable, and Devils on the Doorstep has been suppressed by the Chinese government. Jerome Silbergeld gives these two important films careful and extended study in Body in Question. He uses cinema and photography, political history, anthropology and philosophy, Chinese rhetorical traditions, and concepts of justice to explore the films' visual complexity and intellectual force, providing a unique look at the artistry and pressing concerns of Chinese cinema today. An accompanying DVD includes major clips from both films.
西方视角的独特之处和偏见都不可避免。很怀疑作者懂不懂中文,以西方对中国研究的文献为基础理解中国,得到的无非是想象中的东方
评分《鬼子来了》部分:1. 说得好听点是文章从cinematic style到thematic interpretation、historical/cultural/social investigation面面俱到,不好听点就是逻辑跳跃、缺乏中心论点(先讲姜文这部的摄影如何在新中国强调contrivance的摄影中独树一帜到电影中的animal和中国人的racism blabla);2. 强烈不认同文章最后说战争只是situational的观点,讲真,拿一个七十年代的心理学/行为学实验做支撑真的有说服力吗?实验适用的是个individual层面上的问题,而战争显然不是;3. 对电影内容的复述太啰嗦,而且还有几处有误;4. 您08年的书怎么不讲姜文在《鬼》后其实还拍了电影呢??
评分这书刷新了我对姜文电影的世界观。作者对《阳光灿烂的日子》的解析真是奇葩又独特,并且还理有据令人信服。看了此影评后读其他对这部电影的解读都算过家家。但问题是:根据Silbergeld对姜文的理解,若《阳光》真的是对理想的幻灭与反怀旧,那么姜文在《让子弹飞》里表达的情怀则站在了此论点的对立面。
评分《鬼子来了》部分:1. 说得好听点是文章从cinematic style到thematic interpretation、historical/cultural/social investigation面面俱到,不好听点就是逻辑跳跃、缺乏中心论点(先讲姜文这部的摄影如何在新中国强调contrivance的摄影中独树一帜到电影中的animal和中国人的racism blabla);2. 强烈不认同文章最后说战争只是situational的观点,讲真,拿一个七十年代的心理学/行为学实验做支撑真的有说服力吗?实验适用的是个individual层面上的问题,而战争显然不是;3. 对电影内容的复述太啰嗦,而且还有几处有误;4. 您08年的书怎么不讲姜文在《鬼》后其实还拍了电影呢??
评分这书刷新了我对姜文电影的世界观。作者对《阳光灿烂的日子》的解析真是奇葩又独特,并且还理有据令人信服。看了此影评后读其他对这部电影的解读都算过家家。但问题是:根据Silbergeld对姜文的理解,若《阳光》真的是对理想的幻灭与反怀旧,那么姜文在《让子弹飞》里表达的情怀则站在了此论点的对立面。
评分
评分
评分
评分
Body in Question pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024