具體描述
Summary
"This is an excellently written, witty, and challenging book. It extends a Foucauldian debate on 'discipline' through an interesting critique of Kantian moralism and opens up new perspectives on a principled resistance in philosophy."
-- Martin Donougho, University of South Carolina
"Anyone interested in the current debates on poststructuralism and postmodernism, as well as anyone interested in the history of philosophy, or the connection between more 'traditional' philosophy and 'poststructuralist' philosophy, will find this work accessible and important." -- Tamsin Lorraine, Swarthmore College
Andrew Cutrofello demonstrates that in light of Michel Foucault's genealogical criticisms of the juridical model of power, it is possible to develop a postjuridical model of Kantian critique. Recasting game theory's celebrated "prisoner's dilemma" in Foucauldian terms, Cutrofello illuminates the techniques of mutual betrayal that train bodies to reason themselves into complicity with forces of subjugation. He shows how a genealogically reformulated version of Kantian ethics can provide the basic parameters of a "discipline of resistance" to such forces, and he argues for a more nuanced assessment of the stakes involved in the demise of philosophy as a disciplinary formation. Along the way, Cutrofello presents fascinating readings of Kant's own "care of the self" ethic, drawing on the conceptual resources of Gilles Deleuze, Jacques Lacan, and Luce Irigaray. This tour-de-force will prompt social theorists to reconsider the way power functions in our modern/postmodern world.
"This is a powerful and provocative study of Kant, Foucault, and the construct of freedom. It focuses on what I believe to be the raging question among continental philosophers today: How in the wake of postmodernism can philosophers find a basis for normative theory?
"It will prove useful and exciting not only to the many continental philosophers who are finding that they can no longer ignore normative issues but also to theorists across the disciplines." --Cynthia Willett, University of Kansas
Andrew Cutrofello is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at St. Mary's College in Notre Dame, Indiana.
作者簡介
Andrew Cutrofello has a long-standing interest in meta-philosophical disagreements about the philosophical enterprise. His book Continental Philosophy: A Contemporary Introduction (Routledge, 2005) explores the meta-philosophical significance of the disciplinary distinction between analytic and continental philosophy. On his account, this notoriously vague yet institutionally powerful distinction is best understood as a legacy of the Kantian critical project, indeed as a struggle over the Kantian legacy itself. To each of the four questions that Kant took to be fundamental to philosophy, the first analytic and continental philosophers proposed not alternative answers but alternative questions, and ever since it has been difficult for the inheritors of these new questions to explain themselves to one another. Having used Shakespeare's depiction of the Wars of the Roses as a rhetorical frame for his presentation of the analytic/continental division, Cutrofello is now exploring the role that Shakespeare himself has played in the history of philosophy. For the past thirteen years, he has been a professor at Loyola University Chicago. In addition to Continental Philosophy: A Contemporary Introduction he is the author of three other books, including The Owl at Dawn: A Sequel to Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit (State University of New York, 1995).
目錄資訊
Acknowledgments
Preface
1. The Search for a Metadeduction of the Juridical Model of Critique
2. From the Transcendental to the Genealogical and Back: Kant avec Foucault?
3. The Role of Discipline in Kant's Court of Reason
4. The White Wall above Me and the Black Hole within Me: Kant's Care of the Self
5. The Problem of Heteronomy Recast: How Do You Get Out of a Disciplinary Matrix?
6. From Principles to Strategies: A "B Edition" of Kant's Second Critique
7. "The Name of Lampe Must Now Be Entirely Forgotten": Kant in an Imaginary Voice
8. Practicing Philosophy As a Discipline of Resistance
Notes
Bibliography
Index of Names
· · · · · · (收起)
讀後感
用戶評價
初次接觸這本書時，我有些擔心它會過於沉悶或專業化，畢竟“紀律”與“批判”這兩個詞匯聽起來就帶著一股嚴肅的禁欲氣息。然而，這本書齣乎意料地具有一種強烈的節奏感和敘事張力。作者的高明之處在於，他沒有將批判變成一種單純的否定，而是將其融入到對現有秩序運行機製的精細描摹之中。書中對特定曆史時期社會管理模式的分析，簡直像一颱運轉精準的手術刀，層層剝離齣那些看似自然實則建構起來的規範。閱讀時，我常常需要停下來，反復琢磨某一個關鍵句子的含義，因為它往往蘊含著多重指涉。它不是一本可以囫圇吞棗的書，它要求讀者投入全部的注意力，去感受文字背後那種微妙的、滲透性的張力。最讓我震撼的是它如何將理論與實踐緊密結閤，每一個抽象的概念都能夠在具體的製度或生活場景中找到堅實的落點，使得“批判”不再是空中樓閣，而是觸手可及的現實鬥爭。
评分我必須承認，這本書的閱讀門檻不低，它要求讀者對社會學、哲學乃至部分曆史學的基礎概念有所瞭解，但請相信我，一旦你跨過最初的幾頁，隨之而來的迴報是巨大的。作者的文字風格猶如一位技藝高超的雕塑傢，每一筆都精準有力，絕無冗餘的贅述。他擅長構建對比鮮明的場景，比如對某種公開的“仁慈”與隱秘的“管控”之間的並置分析，讀來令人不寒而栗，卻又不得不承認其洞察的精準。這本書的結構設計極其巧妙，每一章既獨立成篇，又相互支撐，共同編織成一張無懈可擊的分析網絡。我尤其欣賞作者在處理“反抗”主題時的復雜性，他沒有簡單地歌頌反抗，而是深入挖掘瞭反抗行為本身可能被吸收和異化的風險，這種深刻的自我反思，讓整本書的批判維度上升到瞭一個新的高度。它讓人思考的不是如何推翻舊秩序，而是如何在一個被規訓的世界中，保持思想的不屈服。
评分這本著作給我最深遠的印象，是它所散發齣的那種穿透曆史迷霧的銳利目光。它不像某些流行的理論讀物那樣，隻停留於錶麵現象的批判，而是直指那些深植於製度和語言結構中的權力邏輯。作者對於“慣例”如何成為“自然法則”的論證，堪稱教科書級彆的演示。我發現自己在日常生活中，開始對那些被我們習以為常的事物——比如排隊、比如標準化的教育流程——産生一種健康的懷疑和審視。書中的語言節奏變化多端，有時如同法庭上的質詢，步步緊逼，要求對方給齣無可辯駁的解釋；有時又像一位哲人，引人進入悠長而深邃的沉思之中。它成功地將宏大的曆史敘事與微觀的個人心理活動聯係起來，使讀者在閱讀時，既能感受到一種全局性的震撼，又能清晰地定位到自身在這一場復雜博弈中的位置。這是一部值得反復研讀，並在不同人生階段都能讀齣新意的作品。
评分這本書的閱讀體驗，更像是一次精神上的長跑訓練。它節奏舒緩卻後勁十足，不追求即時的轟動效應，而是專注於構建一個嚴密且無法輕易攻破的思想框架。我對作者處理復雜議題時的冷靜剋製深錶贊賞，他避免瞭情緒化的錶達，而是用一種近乎冷靜的、科學的觀察視角，來剖析那些常常引人激憤的社會現象。其中關於“自我主體性”的探討，尤其發人深省，它迫使我重新審視自己日常生活中那些看似自主的選擇，究竟在多大程度上是真正自由的。書中引用的文學和藝術作品作為佐證，更是點睛之筆，它們為冰冷的理論賦予瞭血肉和情感，使得閱讀過程充滿瞭一種跨學科的愉悅。我發現，每當我試圖用舊有的思維定式去套用書中的觀點時，都會發現自己的框架已被拓展或坍塌，這種被挑戰的感覺，恰恰是閱讀的終極樂趣所在。
评分這本書簡直是思想的饕餮盛宴，從翻開第一頁起，我就被作者那精妙絕倫的邏輯和鞭闢入裏的洞察力所吸引。它並非那種堆砌著晦澀術語的學術巨著，相反，它以一種近乎詩意的散文筆觸，帶領讀者在知識的迷宮中穿梭。閱讀過程就像是參與一場深刻的哲學辯論，每推進一步，都伴隨著對既有觀念的顛覆與重塑。作者對權力結構、社會規訓的解構，既有宏大的理論視野，又不乏對個體經驗的細緻關懷。我特彆欣賞其中關於“可見性”與“不可見性”的論述，它深刻揭示瞭在當代社會中，我們如何被觀看，又如何自覺地進行自我規訓。書中對曆史案例的引用，更是信手拈來，且角度新穎，讓人仿佛置身於一個不斷反思的永恒現場。讀完後，我感到腦海中許多原本模糊的綫條突然變得清晰起來，一種久違的批判性思維的快感油然而生，讓人迫不及待地想與人分享那些被激發的思考火花。這本書的價值，在於它提供的不是答案，而是更優質的問題。
评分 评分 评分 评分 评分相關圖書
本站所有內容均為互聯網搜索引擎提供的公開搜索信息，本站不存儲任何數據與內容，任何內容與數據均與本站無關，如有需要請聯繫相關搜索引擎包括但不限於百度，google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 qciss.net All Rights Reserved. 小哈圖書下載中心 版权所有