Here is biographical study blended smoothly with murder mystery. The cause of Mozart s death remains a mystery after many attempts to explain it. Despite the great success of Amadeus, the idea that the composer Salieri poisoned Mozart out of jealousy is generally not credited. Francis Carr skillfully reopens the question of poisoning, but with a new and plausible suspect, having set the stage with an analysis of Mozart s and Constanze s marriage.
It may seem hard for the general reader to believe that so little is known about parts of the life of so great a figure as Mozart. No matter which biography of Mozart you pick up, you find efforts to explain certain blanks in the life of a man so celebrated in his own time. So, too, the odd manner of his funeral and burial. Carr s thesis brings together and explains a number of these mysteries.
In the second half of the book, Carr does a superb job of documenting inconsistencies and reopening the question of why Mozart s remains were treated the way they were. In this matter he masterfully sweeps away the weak explanations of major biographers, especially those around the burial laws of Emperor Joseph II.
The book has a good many passages quoted from Mozart letters, a practice that I generally find less than happy, being so often used as padding. But here the letters are skillfully used to establish Mozart s feelings and attitudes towards his wife as well as providing key testimony from figures such as Constanze s sister Sophie. The absence of letters at certain times, presumably destroyed by Constanze, is itself a line of evidence. Because the heart of the book - Mozart s relationship with his wife and what happened to cause Mozart s death and strange burial - can be little more than an extended essay, the author may be forgiven some padding.
The book is well enough done that you may find yourself reading it in one sitting, just as I did.
If you had previously rejected the idea that Constanze was an inappropriate wife for Mozart, believing it based in prejudice and being aware, through letters, of Mozart s great affection for her, this book may just change your mind.
我發現自己對這本書的態度是矛盾的。一方麵,它的文筆流暢至極,帶有某種古典主義的莊重感,閱讀體驗本身就是一種享受;但另一方麵,它對人性的刻畫又顯得過於冷峻,缺乏溫暖的撫慰。書中那些人物,無論地位高低,似乎都戴著一副無法摘下的麵具,他們的情感錶達總是被一層厚厚的禮儀規範所包裹。我一直在尋找一些人與人之間真誠的、不設防的交流瞬間,但它們寥寥無幾,即便有,也常常以某種遺憾告終。作者似乎對“完美”抱有極度的警惕,他擅長捕捉人物內心深處的脆弱、自負和不可避免的失敗。這種對缺陷的著迷,雖然使得作品的思想深度大大增加,但對於尋求情感共鳴的讀者來說,可能會感到一絲寒意。這本書更像是一麵鏡子,清晰地反射齣那個時代的局限性,以及人性中那些永恒的、難以剋服的弱點,需要讀者具備相當的心理承受能力去直麵這些真相。
评分老實說,我期待的可能是一部更‘傳記式’的敘述,結果讀到的卻是某種充滿象徵意味的散文詩。文字的密度極高,仿佛每一個詞語都經過瞭反復的捶打和篩選,很少有冗餘的句子。這本書的結構非常奇特,它似乎並不遵循嚴格的時間綫索,而是像音樂的變奏麯一樣,在不同的主題和情感之間來迴穿梭。我特彆喜歡其中對“靈感”這一概念的哲學探討,作者似乎並不把天纔視為一種神賜的特權,而是將其描繪成一種近乎病態的、無法自控的內在驅動力,這種驅動力與現實生活的瑣碎、經濟的拮據形成瞭尖銳的矛盾。書中對於細節的關注達到瞭令人發指的程度,比如對某種特定樂器製作工藝的描述,或是對信件中墨水化學特性的分析,這些看似與主綫無關的“旁枝末節”,卻構成瞭那個時代堅實的物質基礎,讓一切變得無比真實。這本書需要靜下心來,最好是在一個安靜的下午,伴著一杯濃鬱的黑咖啡,纔能領略其文字的韻味和深層意圖,否則很容易被錶麵的晦澀所勸退。
评分這本書的視角非常獨特,它幾乎避開瞭所有那些已經被無數次重復敘述的“高光時刻”,轉而聚焦於那些被曆史塵封的、邊緣化的片段。讀來最大的感受是“陌生化”,它成功地讓你對那些你自以為已經非常熟悉的人物和事件,産生一種全新的、甚至略帶批判性的審視。作者似乎對“浪漫主義”濾鏡抱持著一種審慎的態度,他更傾嚮於展示現實的粗糲和藝術傢的窘迫,而非美化他們的睏境。例如,書中對演齣季的組織、樂譜齣版的商業運作的描述,就遠比對幾首協奏麯的分析來得詳盡和引人入勝。這感覺更像是一部社會史研究的側記,而非傳統意義上的藝術評論。我特彆欣賞作者運用對比的技巧,將宏偉的音樂廳內部的奢靡與後巷裏的貧睏生活並置,這種強烈的反差,有效地揭示瞭那個社會結構性的不公。讀完後,你不會得到一個簡單的、光鮮亮麗的偶像形象,而是會對那個時代復雜性有一個更深層次的理解。
评分這本書給我的整體感覺是“碎片化”的詩意構建。它不像一本綫性的傳記,更像是一部由無數未完成的草稿、未寄齣的信件、被遺忘的筆記和模糊的記憶殘片精心拼貼而成的馬賽剋。作者采用瞭大量非傳統的敘事手法,比如在關鍵情節處突然中斷,轉而深入探討一個看似不相關的曆史事件,這種跳躍性要求讀者具備很強的聯想能力和耐心去重建敘事的主乾。我特彆喜歡書中對“沉默”的運用,有些場景與其用冗長的對話來描繪衝突,不如用大段的空白和環境描寫來暗示人物之間無法言說的張力,這種“留白”的藝術處理,高明之至。它挑戰瞭我們對於“清晰”敘事的傳統期待,迫使我們去參與到意義的創造過程中。這本書更像是一部需要被“解碼”的藝術品,而不是一部簡單講述故事的讀物。它最終呈現的,與其說是一個人物的生平,不如說是一種特定精神狀態在特定曆史時空下的迴響。
评分這部作品,坦白說,初讀時我有些摸不著頭腦,它像一團層層疊疊的絲綢,你得耐下性子去解開每一層褶皺纔能窺見其下的紋理。作者對於十八世紀末維也納社會風俗的描摹細緻入微,那種貴族階層的虛僞和市民階層的躁動不安,仿佛能讓人聞到空氣中彌漫的脂粉香和黴味。我尤其欣賞其中對“藝術贊助人”這一群體的刻畫,他們並非單純的慈善傢,而是精明的商人,對待天纔如同對待一件昂貴的、易碎的藝術品,需要小心翼翼地展示,卻又時刻準備著將其收入囊中以牟取私利。書中關於音樂沙龍的場景描寫尤其生動,那些不甚高明的評論傢們如何用一套陳舊的術語來評判劃時代的創新,那種尷尬的、充滿算計的社交禮儀,讀來令人不勝唏噓。它不僅僅是關於一個音樂傢的側麵記錄,更是一部關於那個特定時代,個體如何在宏大敘事與世俗壓力之間掙紮的社會浮世繪。我花瞭好幾陣子纔適應這種略顯疏離的敘事腔調,但一旦進入情境,便很難自拔,那種曆史的厚重感和人物內心的微妙波動,被處理得恰到好處,不煽情,卻足夠有力。
評分評分
評分
評分
評分
本站所有內容均為互聯網搜索引擎提供的公開搜索信息,本站不存儲任何數據與內容,任何內容與數據均與本站無關,如有需要請聯繫相關搜索引擎包括但不限於百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 qciss.net All Rights Reserved. 小哈圖書下載中心 版权所有