The Civil War represented a momentous change in the character of war. It combined the projection of military might across a continent on a scale never before seen with an unprecedented mass mobilization of peoples. Yet despite the revolutionizing aspects of the Civil War, its leaders faced the same uncertainties and vagaries of chance that have vexed combatants since the days of Thucydides and the Peloponnesian War. A Savage War sheds critical new light on this defining chapter in military history.
.
In a masterful narrative that propels readers from the first shots fired at Fort Sumter to the surrender of Robert E. Lee's army at Appomattox, Williamson Murray and Wayne Wei-siang Hsieh bring every aspect of the battlefield vividly to life. They show how this new way of waging war was made possible by the powerful historical forces unleashed by the Industrial Revolution and the French Revolution, yet how the war was far from being simply a story of the triumph of superior machines. Despite the Union’s material superiority, a Union victory remained in doubt for most of the war. Murray and Hsieh paint indelible portraits of Abraham Lincoln, Ulysses S. Grant, William Tecumseh Sherman, and other major figures whose leadership, judgment, and personal character played such decisive roles in the fate of a nation. They also examine how the Army of the Potomac, the Army of Northern Virginia, and the other major armies developed entirely different cultures that influenced the war’s outcome.
.
A military history of breathtaking sweep and scope, A Savage War reveals how the Civil War ushered in the age of modern warfare.
.
【Review】
.
"[An] illuminating, ambitious and unsentimental history. . . . Exceptionally lucid."
--Fergus M. Bordewich, Wall Street Journal
.
"[An] outstanding account of the American Civil War. . . . This expertly written narrative will draw in anyone with an interest in the Civil War at any knowledge level."
--Library Journal, starred review
.
"A genuinely fresh, persuasive perspective on the Civil War. . . . [A Savage War] will make even readers with a strong knowledge of the war think about how it was fought and why it ended as it did. A winner for Civil War history buffs."
--Kirkus, starred review
.
"[A] new and interesting military history of the American Civil War."
--Francis P. Sempa, New York Journal of Books
.
"The best, clearest, and most instructive military history of the Civil War I have ever read. . . . [A Savage War] hit a home run."
--Tyler Cowen, Marginal Revolution
.
"[F]or those who want to understand the key decisions that determined the outcome of the [Civil War], the organization of the opposing armies and their deployments, the role of logistics and intelligence, and the moments of inspired generalship (and missed opportunities), it is hard to imagine a better book than this."
--Lawrence D. Freedman, Foreign Affairs
.
"Widely published and respected military historians Murray and Hsieh produce a fresh look at the US Civil War. . . . An important, impressive book."
--Choice
.
"Murray and Hsieh offer keen insights on the crossroads of social, political, and technological drivers that produced what the authors call the first modern war. . . . The mini-portraits of Abraham Lincoln, Ulysses S. Grant, Robert E. Lee, and William T. Sherman sprinkled throughout that narrative are superb, and the critiques of Jeff Davis and the hapless Henry Halleck are devastating. . . . [A] stimulating contribution to the field that will captivate readers. [A Savage War] belongs on the shelf of students of war, right next to their worn copy of McPherson’s classic, Battle Cry of Freedom."
--Lt. Col. F.G. Hoffman, Marine Corps Gazette
.
"Hsieh and Murray illuminate the broader political and cultural forces that shaped the [Civil War’s] course while also giving due credit to the impact of contingency and human action.. . . . A Savage War will appeal to both academic and popular audiences with its resonance, accessible prose, and fresh treatment of the events that still captivate America’s public consciousness over 150 years later."
--Lt. Andrew L. Hargroder, Civil War Book Review
.
"If you think that there is nothing new to write about the Civil War, this book will prove you wrong."
--H. R. McMaster, author of Dereliction of Duty: Lyndon Johnson, Robert McNamara, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Lies That Led to Vietnam
.
"More than just another narrative of the Civil War, this thoughtful and often provocative book is an engaging analysis of the leadership, personalities, and strategies of both sides during America's great nineteenth-century trauma."
--Craig L. Symonds, author of Lincoln and His Admirals
.
"A Savage War is not just a riveting military narrative of the American Civil War written by two military historians with singular pragmatic experience, but a rare and much needed strategic assessment of the aims and methods of the Union and the Confederacy--highlighted with incisive, blunt--and persuasive-- appraisals of all the major generals and supreme commanders."
--Victor Davis Hanson, author of Carnage and Culture and The Savior Generals
.
"A Savage War offers a splendid overview of the greatest military trauma in United States history. The authors explore Union and Confederate martial culture, navigate with a sure step through campaigns and battles, and assess leaders convincingly--all the while challenging hoary misconceptions about the conflict. Readers new to the topic, as well as more veteran students, will turn to this book with profit."
--Gary W. Gallagher, author of The Union War
.
"A Savage War is a marvelous book. Iconoclastic, endlessly fascinating, and wide-ranging, this work is a singular achievement, something sure to delight Civil War buffs. A must-read."
--Jay Winik, author of 1944 and April 1865
.
"Murray and Hsieh bring verve, insight, and originality to their account of the Civil War. In a crowded field, A Savage War still stands out as a book of required reading even for specialists."
--Allan R. Millett, author of The War for Korea, 1950-1951: They Came from the North
.
"[A] very important new history of the American Civil War by two important historians."
--Newt Gingrich
.
"A genuinely fresh set of insights about the Civil War. Murray and Hsieh have crafted a military narrative that goes well beyond anything else in the literature."
--James McPherson, Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era
.
"Forceful and convincing. Murray and Hsieh have succeeded in producing a very accessible book about a very complex series of events . . . A model of how to write military history."
--John Gooch, author of Mussolini and His Generals: The Armed Forces and Fascist Foreign Policy, 1922–1940
Williamson Murray serves as a Minerva Fellow at the Naval War College. He graduated from Yale University in 1963 with honors in history. He then served five years as an officer in the US Air Force, including a tour in Southeast Asia with the 314th Tactical Airlift Wing (C-130s). He returned to Yale University, where he received his PhD in military-diplomatic history under advisers Hans Gatzke and Donald Kagan. He taught two years in the Yale history department before moving on to Ohio State University in fall 1977 as a military and diplomatic historian; in 1987 he received the Alumni Distinguished Teaching Award. He retired from Ohio State in 1995 as a professor emeritus of history.
.
Wayne Wei-siang Hsieh teaches military history at the United States Naval Academy, whose faculty he joined in 2005. He also served as a State Department political officer in Iraq between July 2008 and June 2009, where he managed civilian US Government efforts in Tuz, Iraq. He is one of the co-authors of A SAVAGE WAR: A MILITARY HISTORY OF THE CIVIL WAR and the author of WEST POINTERS AND THE CIVIL WAR: THE OLD ARMY IN WAR AND PEACE, along with numerous academic articles.
评分
评分
评分
评分
这本书的叙事节奏简直是一部精心编排的交响乐,起伏跌宕,扣人心弦。作者对于人物心理的刻画细腻入微,仿佛能透过文字直接触摸到角色内心的挣扎与抉择。我尤其欣赏他如何巧妙地运用环境描写来烘托气氛,那些关于宏大战争场面的描绘,既有史诗般的磅礴气势,又不失对个体士兵恐惧与绝望的精准捕捉。读到某些转折点时,我甚至能清晰地感受到心跳的加速,不得不放下书本,深吸一口气才能继续。情节的推进干净利落,却又不失铺垫的深度,每一个看似偶然的事件背后,都埋藏着早已布下的伏笔,待到真相大白时,那种豁然开朗的震撼感令人拍案叫绝。这本书的优点在于它拒绝平庸,它敢于直面人性的复杂和战争的残酷,而不是用廉价的英雄主义来粉饰太平。它迫使读者去思考,在极端环境下,道德的界限究竟在哪里,以及生存的真正代价是什么。这种深度思考的空间,是如今许多快餐式阅读作品所无法比拟的。
评分这本书的语言风格简直是一种享受,它带着一种古典的韵味,却又在关键时刻爆发出惊人的现代感和力量。作者的遣词造句考究而精准,仿佛他手中的笔就是一把雕刻刀,将每一个场景、每一种情感都打磨得棱角分明。我尤其留意到他对于意象的运用,那些反复出现的象征符号,在不同的章节中被赋予了新的含义,为整个文本增添了丰富的解读层次。阅读过程中,我常常需要放慢速度,细细品味那些精彩的段落,甚至会忍不住去查阅一些生僻的词汇,以求更深入地理解作者的深意。与那些追求速度和爽感的作品不同,这本书更像是一场马拉松,考验的不仅是耐力,更是对文字美学的鉴赏力。它探讨的主题宏大而深刻,涉及历史的必然性与个体命运的抗争,读完后留下的余味,久久不散,让人久久沉浸其中,回味无穷。
评分这本书最让我感到震撼的是它对于战争伦理的探讨,它毫不留情地撕开了“正义”外衣下的血腥与荒谬。作者似乎对人性的阴暗面有着近乎冷酷的洞察力,他笔下的角色没有绝对的好人或坏人,只有在特定压力下做出选择的“人”。我注意到,作者非常擅长使用对话来推动情节和揭示矛盾,那些充满张力的辩论和沉默的对峙,比任何激烈的战斗场面都更能体现冲突的本质。特别是主角面对那些道德困境时的挣扎,读来令人心痛,那不是简单的善恶抉择,而是两种“正确”之间的两难之痛。这本书的社会批判性极强,它超越了单纯的娱乐范畴,直接指向了权力结构、意识形态对个体精神的腐蚀。它迫使我反思,在集体狂热面前,保持清醒的头脑需要付出多大的代价。
评分我必须承认,这本书的结构设计是极其大胆且成功的。它采用了非线性的叙事手法,将时间线打碎重组,用碎片化的视角来拼凑出一个完整的历史图景。起初,这种跳跃感可能会让一些读者感到困惑,但我坚持了下来,并最终被这种叙事方式所带来的沉浸感所折服。通过不同角色的回忆和日记片段,作者成功地构建了一个多维度的世界,每个角色的声音都真实可信,他们的经历交织在一起,揭示出事件更深层次的真相。这种拼图式的阅读体验,极大地增强了读者的主动性,我们不再是被动接受信息,而是在阅读的过程中主动参与建构故事。这种叙事技巧的使用,恰到好处地呼应了主题——即历史真相往往是被不同力量扭曲和遮蔽的,需要我们自己去努力还原。这是一部需要“投入”时间才能收获巨大回报的作品,绝对值得细细品味。
评分整体来看,这本书在细节的考据和历史氛围的营造上达到了一个极高的水准。作者显然是下了苦功去研究那个特定时期的社会风貌、军事术语乃至生活细节。阅读时,我仿佛能闻到硝烟的味道,能感受到当时社会阶层之间的森严壁垒。这种真实感,使得书中的虚构故事也具有了无可辩驳的说服力。我尤其欣赏作者对配角的塑造,他们虽然戏份不多,但每一个都栩栩如生,他们的命运与宏大叙事紧密相连,共同构筑了这个时代的悲歌。与那些情节驱动型的作品不同,这本书更注重“存在”本身——即个体如何在历史的洪流中努力维持其尊严与自我认同。对于那些追求文学深度和历史厚重感的读者来说,这本书无疑是一次不可多得的阅读盛宴,它不仅讲述了一个故事,更留给我们一个深刻的时代切片。
评分 评分 评分 评分 评分本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度,google,bing,sogou 等
© 2026 qciss.net All Rights Reserved. 小哈图书下载中心 版权所有