图书标签: 历史 Ankersmit 理论 歷史編纂學 歷史學理論 歷史再現 新歷史主義 史学理论
发表于2024-11-22
Meaning, Truth, and Reference in Historical Representation pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
In this book, the noted intellectual historian Frank Ankersmit provides a systematic account of the problems of reference, truth, and meaning in historical writing. He works from the conviction that the historicist account of historical writing, associated primarily with Leopold von Ranke and Wilhelm von Humboldt, is essentially correct but that its original idealist and romanticist idiom needs to be translated into more modern terms. Rehabilitating historicism for the contemporary philosophy of history, he argues, "reveals the basic truths about the nature of the past itself, how we relate to it, and how we make sense of the past in historical writing."
At the heart of Ankersmit's project is a sharp distinction between interpretation and representation. The historical text, he holds, is first and foremost a representation of some part of the past, not an interpretation. The book's central chapters address the concept of historical representation from the perspectives of reference, truth, and meaning. Ankersmit then goes on to discuss the possible role of experience in the history writing, which leads directly to a consideration of subjectivity and ethics in the historian’s practice. Ankersmit concludes with a chapter on political history, which he maintains is the "basis and condition of all other variants of historical writing." Ankersmit’s rehabilitation of historicism is a powerfully original and provocative contribution to the debate about the nature of historical writing.
感慨下,还在同时看大陆哲学和分析哲学的人,居然在历史届。而这些人写的历史理论,practising历史学家又是不看的。学者这份职业孤独怪谁?遍地都是聪明人然而遍地都在砌墙画圈
评分也算他的集大成作?极好极好,开阔而清晰,盘旋在一些最基本的问题上。开篇直言自己站在兰克和洪堡的历史主义一边的,他们的Historical ideas的概念,一个时代/国家的独特性,历史现象只要在和其进行联系时才能被解释,就像解释人的行为会联系到“性格”。但是和兰克们不一样,他认为这种“观念”不是内在于历史本身,而在历史学家关于过去的言说里。核心的再现理论,正如符号有denotation和connotation,他将再现也看作三重的,representation, represented reality和representation's presented,警告不能弄混后两者的关系,涉及这样的再现的真理性问题时,套海德格尔认为再现的真理就是现实在再现中向我们显露的。
评分飞机上读完。少见的Historismus表述,也是Ankersmit的集大成之作了。重拾兰克路线试图与当代史学理论尤其是和近数十年都发展迟缓的历史主义接驳,关于时间、表现的讨论似乎有点现象学俺基础薄弱还有不少问题……最后回到新政治史的路线上。中译其实不错,只不过我笨读不下去TT
评分飞机上读完。少见的Historismus表述,也是Ankersmit的集大成之作了。重拾兰克路线试图与当代史学理论尤其是和近数十年都发展迟缓的历史主义接驳,关于时间、表现的讨论似乎有点现象学俺基础薄弱还有不少问题……最后回到新政治史的路线上。中译其实不错,只不过我笨读不下去TT
评分感慨下,还在同时看大陆哲学和分析哲学的人,居然在历史届。而这些人写的历史理论,practising历史学家又是不看的。学者这份职业孤独怪谁?遍地都是聪明人然而遍地都在砌墙画圈
评分
评分
评分
评分
Meaning, Truth, and Reference in Historical Representation pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024